Both gel and acrylic nails offer the promise of long-lasting, polished nails that enhance the natural beauty of one's hands. Acrylics bring the benefit of durability, often favored for their strength, while gels give that glossy, natural appearance, loved for its shine and flexibility. The application, maintenance, and overall costs differ for each, allowing customers to decide what best fits their lifestyle and wallet.

Let's break down the differences between Acrylic and Gel Nails into distinct categories for clearer comprehension:

CATEGORY  ACRYLIC NAILS GEL POLISH NAILS
Composition & Application

Requires proper nail preparation, which includes cleaning, buffing and dehydrating the natural nails before application.

Made by mixing a liquid (monomer) and a powder (polymer). The mixture is then sculpted and shaped over a form or on the natural nails. This paste-like substance hardens over the natural nails.

 The nails are then filed and shaped to the desired length and shape.

 The process can take up to an hour or more, depending on the skill of the nail technician and the desired look.

Requires proper nail preparation, which includes cleaning, buffing and dehydrating the natural nails before application.

Applied using a base coat and gel-based polish and requires curing under a UV/LED lamp

Top coat required.

 The process typically takes 30 minutes to an hour. Still, it can vary depending on the skill of the nail technician and the desired look.

Appearance

Typically thicker, more opaque, and can look more artificial

Glossy finish, shiny, and have a more natural appearance.

Durability

Known for their strength and are resistant to chipping and breaking

can be prone to cracking or chipping if not appropriately maintained, and both need regular fill-ins to preserve their appearance.

Durable but more flexible than acrylics. They can be less resistant to chipping.

can be prone to cracking or chipping if not appropriately maintained, and both need regular fill-ins to preserve their appearance.

Application Time

Takes about an hour or more

Typically takes between 30 minutes to an hour

Maintenance & Removal

Acrylic nails must be filled in every two to three weeks to maintain their appearance. During a fill-in, the technician will remove the grown-out portion of the natural nails and add a new layer of acrylic to the nails.

They are also prone to yellowing or discolouration over time, so regular buffing and cleaning are required to maintain their appearance.

 Acrylic nails are removed by soaking them in acetone for 15-20 minutes, then filing and buffing off the remaining acrylic. This process can be harsh on the natural nails and may cause damage if not done correctly.

Gel nails must also be filled in every two to three weeks to maintain their appearance. During a fill-in, the technician will remove the grown-out portion of the natural nails and add a new layer of gel to the nails.

Gel nails are less prone to yellowing or discolouration than acrylic nails. However, regular cleaning is still required to maintain their appearance.

Gel nails are also removed using acetone that is applied to the nails, wrapped in foil, and left on for 10-15 minutes. The excess can then be gently buffed off. This process is less harsh on the natural nails.

Cost

 Generally less expensive.

Acrylic nails tend to be less expensive than gel nails. Still, the cost can vary depending on location, salon, technician, nail art, length and shape of the nails, and the technician's skill.

 Require regular maintenance, and the costs can add up over time.

 Typically more costly

The cost may vary based on the nails' design, length and shape and the technician's skill.

 Require regular maintenance, and the costs of maintaining them can add up over time.

The price of a UV/LED lamp (needed for gel nails) should also be considered.

Pros

Durability, affordability, low maintenance, variety in design, customizability.

 

Natural look, easy removal, long-lasting, lesser damage to natural nails, and a wide variety of colors.

Cons

Potential for nail damage, less natural appearance, possible allergic reactions due to harsh chemicals.

Need for a UV lamp, typically more expensive, not as robust as acrylics, potential sensitivity to UV light, and the requirement for regular maintenance

 

In conclusion, the choice boils down to individual preference. If strength and affordability are your priorities, acrylic might be your go-to. If you're after a natural look and are willing to invest a bit more, gels could be your match. Whichever you choose, make sure to follow proper maintenance routines and find a skilled technician to ensure the health and beauty of your nails. Remember, both gel and acrylic nails can offer stunning results when done right, but it's crucial to know what you're signing up for. So, pick wisely, enjoy the pampering, and flaunt those fabulous nails!

Author: Margie Van Rensburg

Crystal Clawz offers Gel Products available to anyone, and Acrylic Products available to Qualified Technicians only. www.crystalclawz.co.za